Regarding “The End of the World”:
Holy shit. The new series is going somewhere.
EDIT:
Okay. About the Eccleston thing. Now that the shock is past, and now that it’s clear the season was scripted with this probability in mind, and now that we’ve seen episode two and what it suggests about how the new series will treat its characters, and now that we’ve gone back and read Davies’s comments about his ideas for the show — now where do we sit?
As uncomfortable as it might seem at face value, this could come off as an organic development. Consider the following:
- that the reason Davies “never even considered” bringing back McGann for a regeneration was that he didn’t want to confuse a new audience; he wanted a fresh start
- that the new series is about wonder and horror, and about the relationship between the Doctor and his companion
- that unlike the original Doctor Who, the new series is organized around long-term character arcs
So the question to ask is, what do we get if we kill off the Ninth Doctor and keep Rose on, after the first season? What do we establish by doing this? The answer: a hell of a lot.
It establishes the concept of regeneration right off — or, rather, once the Doctor and Rose have had time to bond, and she’s gotten to think she knows him and become comfortable with who she thinks he is. This allows the show to go into his backstory, and explain that he’s had eight other lives before the one she (and by extension the new audience) knew. And maybe even to visit or flash back to a couple of them, eventually. When the notion has settled in well enough.
This whole concept ties into the innate wonder and horror of the new series. The horror that the Doctor is dead; the wonder that he’s not, and that there’s this whole extra dimension to him that he never mentioned; the horror of realizing even more than before just how alien he is and wondering what else that might imply; the horror of the very nature of the Doctor’s relationship with Rose, of everything she knows about him, coming into question as a result of it; the wonder that even with a new face and personality this can still be the same person; the wonder at all of the centuries and lives of experience and knowledge and pain that Rose had never even had a hint of before.
All of this feeds right into the concept of a character arc. It’s the juiciest kind of meat. This is a cornucopia of material for the Doctor, for Rose, and for their relationship. This is the kind of stuff that the series can work off of for years; that, once it’s established, can carry the series to its eventual end. And until the Doctor regenerates, it ain’t going to get established. All we’ve got is a kind of superficial setup.
Recall that the old series didn’t really get started until Hartnell regenerated into Troughton. Then, suddenly, we had something more to work with. So Hartnell stayed for three seasons, while Eccleston is leaving after one. Eccleston’s episodes are also paced more quickly. We have a lot to establish and we know the rules by now. As Davies said, today all you need to show is the cause and the effect; you don’t need to go through all the motions in between, because we get it already.
Of course it would sort of spoil things if the Doctor were to regenerate after every season. He only has a few lives left, and if the series is to work, he should only lose them when there’s a dramatic purpose to it. So whoever the Tenth Doctor is, he should expect to stick around for a while: Eccleston is a sacrifice to him, after all. He will be what we’ve really been waiting for.
EDIT AGAIN:
And hell. Seems this was all planned after all, and the BBC are just idiots for ruining the surprise.